Tello PID Control Tuning

[marcolli]

Has anyone implemented PID positional control of the Tello? I'm developing a command to send the drone to a target position but I'm unsure about the best approach to tuning my controller. If anyone has implemented this already, what gain values have you used?

For reference, I'm using a very simple PID algorithm which then maps values to the virtual Tello joystick.

 

[VR_Dev]

So positional flying via PIDs is my main goal for my new Tello. I have been making PID based autopilots for years in Kerbal Space Program, and hope I can translate some of that into a Tello application.

I haven't gotten very far into this project but I see tuning as a large, and potentially expensive problem. We can't afford to be just guessing on the values and having the tello blast into a wall. I already have my tello working in Unity, so my plan is to make a basic simulator, which has roughly the same flight characteristics as the real thing. Then hopefully we could get the PID tuning in the right ballpark before moving to the real thing.

Right now I'm working on getting 3D positional tracking set up, then I can begin implementing the PIDs.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Accept third party cookies

 

[marcolli]

So positional flying via PIDs is my main goal for my new Tello. I have been making PID based autopilots for years in Kerbal Space Program, and hope I can translate some of that into a Tello application.

I haven't gotten very far into this project but I see tuning as a large, and potentially expensive problem. We can't afford to be just guessing on the values and having the tello blast into a wall. I already have my tello working in Unity, so my plan is to make a basic simulator, which has roughly the same flight characteristics as the real thing. Then hopefully we could get the PID tuning in the right ballpark before moving to the real thing.

Right now I'm working on getting 3D positional tracking set up, then I can begin implementing the PIDs.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Accept third party cookies

Wow, awesome! Yes ideally simulating the behviour of the Tello would be the best way to tune the controllers but I don't really have the time to do it.

I'm planning to do some trial-and-error tuning with the Tello this week. I'll do it outside so it shouldn't crash into anything. I'm not too bothered about getting an optimum tuning. I'm mainly gonna focus on getting reliably P and I behaviour which will be enough for my needs. I'll let you know how I get on.

 

[Zamzam]

Wow, awesome! Yes ideally simulating the behviour of the Tello would be the best way to tune the controllers but I don't really have the time to do it.

I'm planning to do some trial-and-error tuning with the Tello this week. I'll do it outside so it shouldn't crash into anything. I'm not too bothered about getting an optimum tuning. I'm mainly gonna focus on getting reliably P and I behaviour which will be enough for my needs. I'll let you know how I get on.

Did you get the optimal gains?